Improved Spectral-Norm Bounds for Clustering

Aiming to unify known results about clustering mixtures of distributions under separation conditions, Kumar and Kannan [KK10] introduced a deterministic condition for clustering datasets. They showed that this single deterministic condition encompasses many previously studied clustering assumptions. More specifically, their proximity condition requires that in the target k-clustering, the projection of a point x onto the line joining its cluster center μ and some other center μ, is a large additive factor closer to μ than to μ. This additive factor can be roughly described as k times the spectral norm of the matrix representing the differences between the given (known) dataset and the means of the (unknown) target clustering. Clearly, the proximity condition implies center separation – the distance between any two centers must be as large as the above mentioned bound. In this paper we improve upon the work of Kumar and Kannan [KK10] along several axes. First, we weaken the center separation bound by a factor of √ k, and secondly we weaken the proximity condition by a factor of k (in other words, the revised separation condition is independent of k). Using these weaker bounds we still achieve the same guarantees when all points satisfy the proximity condition. Under the same weaker bounds, we achieve even better guarantees when only (1−ǫ)-fraction of the points satisfy the condition. Specifically, we correctly cluster all but a (ǫ + O(1/c))-fraction of the points, compared to O(kǫ)-fraction of [KK10], which is meaningful even in the particular setting when ǫ is a constant and k = ω(1). Most importantly, we greatly simplify the analysis of Kumar and Kannan. In fact, in the bulk of our analysis we ignore the proximity condition and use only center separation, along with the simple triangle and Markov inequalities. Yet these basic tools suffice to produce a clustering which (i) is correct on all but a constant fraction of the points, (ii) has k-means cost comparable to the k-means cost of the target clustering, and (iii) has centers very close to the target centers. Our improved separation condition allows us to match the results of the Planted Partition Model of McSherry [McS01], improve upon the results of Ostrovsky et al [ORSS06], and improve separation results for mixture of Gaussian models in a particular setting. ∗An extended abstract of this work appears in APPROX-RANDOM 2012 †This work was supported in part by the National Science Foundation under grant CCF-0830540, IIS-1065251, and CCF-1116892 as well as by CyLab at Carnegie Mellon under grants DAAD19-02-1-0389 and W911NF-09-1-0273 from the Army Research Office.